• All American Wrestling
  • Jim Lynam Memorial Tournament (2016)[16]
• All Pro Wrestling
  • APW Worldwide Internet Championship (1 time)
• Alternative Championship Wrestling
  • ACW Heavyweight Championship (1 time)[2][10]
• Chikara
  • Chikara Campeonatos de Parejas (1 time) – with Claudio Castagnoli[10][17]
  • Tag World Grand Prix (2006) – with Claudio Castagnoli[10][17]
• Combat Zone Wrestling
  • CZW Iron Man Championship (1 time)[2][10]
  • CZW World Heavyweight Championship (1 time)[2][10]
  • CZW World Tag Team Championship (2 times) – with Claudio Castagnoli[2][10]
  • Last Team Standing (2006) – with Claudio Castagnoli[2]
• Coliseum Championship Wrestling
  • CCW Heavyweight Championship (3 times)[10]
  • CCW Tag Team Championship (1 time) – with John Caesar[10]
• DDT Pro-Wrestling
  • Ironman Heavymetalweight Championship (1 time)[18]
• Evolve
  • Evolve Championship (1 time)[19]
• Grand Pro Wrestling
  • GPW Heavyweight Championship (1 time)[10][20]
• Hard Core Wrestling
  • HCW Tag Team Championship (1 time) – with Danny Blackheart[2]
• Impact Championship Wrestling
  • ICW Heavyweight Championship (1 time)[2]
• Independent Wrestling Association East Coast
  • IWA East Coast Heavyweight Championship (2 times)[10]
• Independent Wrestling Association Mid-South
  • IWA Mid-South Heavyweight Championship (4 times)[2][10]
  • Strong Style Tournament (2005)[10]
  • Sweet Science Sixteen (2000)[2][10]
  • Ted Petty Invitational (2016)
• Juggalo Championship Wrestling
  • JCW Tag Team Championship (1 time) – with Claudio Castagnoli[21]
• NWA West Virginia / Ohio
  • NWA WV/OH Junior Heavyweight Championship (1 time)[2]
• Northern States Wrestling Alliance
  • NSWA Heavyweight Championship (1 time)[2][10]
• Pro Wrestling Guerrilla
  • PWG World Championship (1 time)[10]
• Pro Wrestling Illustrated
  • PWI ranked him #36 of the 500 best singles wrestlers in the world in the PWI 500 in 2011[22]
• Pro Wrestling Noah
  • Global League Tournament Puroresu Kakutōgi DX Award (2014)[23]
  • Global Tag League Outstanding Performance Award (2015) – with Colt Cabana[24]
  • Global Tag League Technique Award (2014, 2015) – with Colt Cabana[25][24]
• Ring of Honor
  • ROH World Tag Team Championship (2 times) – with Claudio Castagnoli[2][10][26]
  • Survival of the Fittest (2007)[2][10]
  • Tag Wars Tournament (2010) – with Claudio Castagnoli[27]
  • Undisputed World Intergender Heavyweight Tag Team Championship (1 time) – with Sara Del Rey1[2][10]
• SoCal Uncensored Awards
  • Match of the Year (2008) vs. Low Ki at PWG 2008 Battle of Los Angeles – Stage Two, November 2, 2008[28]
  • Match of the Year (2009) vs. Bryan Danielson at PWG Guerre Sans Frontières, September 4, 2009[28]
• Unified Championship Wrestling
  • UCW Television Championship (1 time)[2][10]
• Violent Championship Wrestling
  • VCW Tag Team Championship (2 times) – with Porno the Clown[2][10]
  • VCW Triple Threat Championship (2 times)[2][10]
• westside Xtreme wrestling
  • wXw World Heavyweight Championship (1 time)[2][10][29]
  • wXw World Tag Team Championship (1 time) – with Marc Roudin[2][10][29][30]
  • 16 Carat Gold Tournament (2007, 2014)[2][10][31]
• Wrestling Observer Newsletter
  • Tag Team of the Year (2010) with Claudio Castagnoli[32]
• Xtreme Intense Championship Wrestling
  • XICW Heavyweight Championship (1 time)[10]
• Other achievements
  • Jeff Peterson Cup (2007)[10]

1Championship not officially recognized by Ring of Honor.

แมตช์เดิมพัน