• Bad Boys of Wrestling Federation
  • BBFW Caribbean Championship (1 time)[7]
• DDT Pro-Wrestling
  • Ironman Heavymetalweight Championship (1 time)[8]
• Great Lakes Championship Wrestling
  • GLCW Heavyweight Championship (1 time)
• Global Wrestling Federation
  • GWF Light Heavyweight Championship (2 times)[9][10]
  • GWF Light Heavyweight Championship Tournament (1991)
• Jersey Championship Wrestling
  • JCW Tag Team Championship (1 time) – with Joey Janela[11]
• Legends Pro Wrestling
  • LPW Hall of Fame (2011)
• Metroplex Wrestling
  • MPX Tag Team Champion (1 time) – with Jerome Daniels
• Mid-Eastern Wrestling Federation
  • MEWF Light Heavyweight Championship (1 time)[12]
• NWA Pro Wrestling
  • NWA Heritage Championship (1 time)[13]
• Pro Wrestling America
  • PWA Iron Horse Television Championship (1 time)[14]
  • PWA Light Heavyweight Championship (2 times)[15]
  • PWA Tag Team Championship (1 time) [16] – with Jerry Lynn
• Pro Wrestling Illustrated
  • Comeback of the Year (1998)[17]
  • Tag Team of the Year (1999)[18] – with Kane
  • Ranked #21 of the top 500 singles wrestlers in the PWI 500 in 1997[19]
  • Ranked #177 of the top 500 singles wrestlers of the "PWI Years" in 2003[20]
• South Eastern Wrestling Alliance
  • SEWA Light Heavyweight Championship (1 time)[21]
• Total Nonstop Action Wrestling
  • TNA X Division Championship (1 time)[22]
  • Chris Candido Memorial Tag Team Tournament[23] – with Alex Shelley
• World Championship Wrestling
  • WCW Cruiserweight Championship (1 time)[3][24]
  • WCW World Tag Team Championship (1 time) – with Kevin Nash and Scott Hall1
• World Wrestling Federation/WWE
  • WWF European Championship (2 times)[25]
  • WWF Light Heavyweight Championship (2 times)[26]
  • WCW Cruiserweight Championship (1 time)[24]
  • WWF Tag Team Championship (4 times)[27] – with Marty Jannetty (1), Bob Holly (1), and Kane (2)
  • Slammy Award (1 time)
    • Biggest Heart (1994)
  • WWF World Tag Team Championship Tournament (1995) – with Bob Holly
  • WWE Hall of Fame (2 times)
    • Class of 2019 – as a member of D-Generation X[28]
    • Class of 2020 – as a member of the nWo[29]
• Xtreme Pro Wrestling
  • XPW Television Championship (1 time)[30]
• Wrestling Society X
  • WSX Rumble (shared with Vampiro)

1 – Following an injury to Nash, the nWo invoked "Wolfpac Rules" and named Syxx as co-champion[31]