• High Risk Wrestling
  • HRW Tag Team Championship (1 time) – Fish and O'Reilly[10][11]
• New Japan Pro Wrestling
  • IWGP Junior Heavyweight Tag Team Championship (2 times) – Fish and O'Reilly[8][9]
  • Super Jr. Tag Tournament (2014) – Fish and O'Reilly[7]
• Ring of Honor
  • ROH World Championship (1 time) – O'Reilly
  • ROH World Tag Team Championship (3 times) – Fish and O'Reilly
  • ROH World Television Championship (1 time) – Fish
  • Tag Wars Tournament (2014) – Fish and O'Reilly[6]
  • Survival of the Fittest (2016) – Fish
• Wrestling Observer Newsletter
  • 5 Star Match (2018) Cole vs. Killian Dain, Velveteen Dream, EC3, Ricochet and Lars Sullivan on April 7[12]
  • 5 Star Match (2018) O'Reilly and Strong vs. Tyler Bate and Trent Seven on July 11[13]
• WWE
  • NXT Championship (1 time) – Cole
  • NXT North American Championship (2 times) – Cole (1), Strong (1)
  • NXT Tag Team Championship (3 times) – Fish, O'Reilly, Cole and Strong (1)1, O'Reilly and Strong (1), Fish and O'Reilly (1)
  • Dusty Rhodes Tag Team Classic (2018) – Cole and O'Reilly
  • NXT Year-End Award (6 times)
    • Tag Team of the Year (2018) – O'Reilly and Strong
    • Tag Team of the Year (2019) – Fish and O'Reilly
    • Male Competitor of the Year (2019) – Cole
    • Overall Competitor of the Year (2019) – Cole
    • Match of the Year (2019) vs. Johnny Gargano at NXT TakeOver: New York – Cole
    • Rivalry of the Year (2019) vs. Johnny Gargano – Cole
  • NXT Triple Crown Champion – Cole

1For The Undisputed Era's first reign, Fish and O'Reilly won the title as a duo, with Cole and Strong later being recognized as co-champions under the Freebird Rule.