• Dragon Gate USA
  • Open the United Gate Championship (1 time) – with Anthony Nese and Caleb Konley1[10]
  • Six Man Tag Team Tournament (2014) – with Anthony Nese and Caleb Konley[11]
• Empire State Wrestling
  • Ilio DiPaolo Memorial Cup (2013)[12]
• Florida Championship Wrestling
  • FCW Florida Tag Team Championship (2 times) – with Caylen Croft (2) and Curt Hawkins (1)2[13]
• Full Impact Pro
  • FIP World Heavyweight Championship (1 time)[14]
• New Japan Pro Wrestling
  • IWGP Junior Heavyweight Tag Team Championship (4 times) – with Rocky Romero[15][16][17][18]
  • NEVER Openweight 6-Man Tag Team Championship (1 time) – with Tomohiro Ishii and Toru Yano[19]
  • Super Jr. Tag Tournament (2016) – with Rocky Romero[20]
• New York Wrestling Connection
  • NYWC Heavyweight Championship (1 time)[1]
  • NYWC Hi-Fi Championship (3 times)[1]
  • NYWC Tag Team Championship (1 time) – with Maverick[1]
  • NYWC Hall of Fame (2017)
• Pro Wrestling Guerrilla
  • Dynamite Duumvirate Tag Team Title Tournament (2014) – with Chuck Taylor[21]
• Pro Wrestling Illustrated
  • Ranked No. 91 of the top 500 singles wrestlers in the PWI 500 in 2017[22]
• Westside Xtreme Wrestling
  • wXw World Tag Team Championship (1 time) – with Matt Striker[23]
• WrestleCircus
  • Big Top Tag Team Championship (1 time) – with Rocky Romero[24]

1 When Nese and Konley won the title, Barreta could defend the title with either of them under the Freebird Rule.
2 When Croft and Hawkins won the title, Barreta could defend the title with either of them under the Freebird Rule.