• American Combat Wrestling
  • ACW Heavyweight Championship (1 time)[1]
• Allied Powers Wrestling Federation
  • APWF Cruiserweight Championship (1 time)[14]
• Family Wrestling Entertainment
  • FWE Heavyweight Championship (1 time)[15]
• Fighting Spirit Pro Wrestling
  • FSPW Independent Championship (2 times)[1]
• IWF
  • IWF Heavyweight Championship (1 time)[1]
• Memphis Wrestling
  • Memphis Southern Tag Team Championship (1 time) – with Johnny Devine[1]
• Neo Spirit Pro
  • NSP Independent Championship (1 time)[1]
• Pro Wrestling Illustrated
  • Ranked No. 19 of the top 500 singles wrestlers in the PWI 500 in 2014[16]
• Total Nonstop Action Wrestling
  • NWA World Tag Team Championship (2 times) – with Bobby Roode[1][14]
  • TNA Legends/Global/Television/King of the Mountain Championship (3 times)[14]
  • TNA Knockouts Tag Team Championship (1 time) – with ODB[7]
  • TNA World Beer Drinking Championship (2 time)2[1]
  • TNA World Tag Team Championship (2 times) – with Kaz (1) and Kevin Nash and Scott Hall (1)1[1][5][6]
  • TNA/Impact World (Heavyweight) Championship (2 times)
  • TNA X Division Championship (1 time)[1]
  • TNA Turkey Bowl (2011, 2012)[10]
  • TNA World Cup of Wrestling (2014) – with Bully Ray, Gunner, Eddie Edwards, and ODB
  • King of the Mountain (2016)
  • Seventh TNA Triple Crown Champion
  • Fourth TNA Grand Slam Champion
  • TNA Year End Award for Most Inspirational (2006)[17]
• Wrestling Observer Newsletter
  • Worst Worked Match of the Year (2006) TNA Reverse Battle Royal on TNA Impact![18]
• WWE
  • NXT Tag Team Championship (1 time) – with Alexander Wolfe[19]
  • NXT Year-End Award (1 time)
    • Tag Team of the Year (2017) – with Alexander Wolfe and Killain Dain[20]
• Xtreme Wrestling Coalition
  • XWC World Heavyweight Championship (1 time)[1]

1 Young defended the championship with either Hall or Nash under the Freebird Rule.
2 Championship not officially recognized by TNA.