• Action Packed Wrestling
  • APW Chester Heavyweight Championship (2 times)[6]
• East Coast Championship Wrestling
  • ECCW Tag Team Championship (1 time)[6]
• Ground Xero Wrestling
  • GXW Heavyweight Championship (1 time)[7]
• National Wrestling Alliance
  • NWA National Heavyweight Championship (1 time)[8]
  • Future Legends Cup (2010)[9]
• NWA Anarchy
  • NWA Anarchy Heavyweight Championship (1 time)[10]
  • NWA Anarchy Tag Team Championship (1 time)1 – with Kimo and Abomination[11]
• NWA Charlotte
  • NWA Mid-Atlantic Heritage Championship (1 time)[12]
• Pro Wrestling Illustrated
  • Ranked No. 40 of the top 500 singles wrestlers in the PWI 500 in 2014[13]
• Premiere Wrestling Xperience
  • PWX Innovative Television Championship (1 time)[14]
• Showtime All-Star Wrestling
  • SAW International Heavyweight Championship (1 time)[15]
• Southern Wrestling Association
  • Rhymer Cup (2016) - with John Skyler
• Total Nonstop Action Wrestling
  • TNA Television Championship (1 time)[16][17]
  • TNA World Tag Team Championship (1 time) – with James Storm[18]
  • Feast or Fired (2013 – World Heavyweight Championship contract)[19]
  • Feast or Fired (2013 – World Tag Team Championship contract)2
  • TNA World Cup (2014) – with Bully Ray, Eric Young, Eddie Edwards and ODB
  • TNA World Cup (2015) – with Jeff Hardy, Davey Richards, Rockstar Spud, Crazzy Steve and Gail Kim
  • TNA Classic (2015)
• WrestleForce
  • WrestleForce Championship (1 time)[20]

1Shatter defended the title with either Kimo or Abomination under the Freebird Rule.
2Won this contract from Ethan Carter III in a tag team ladder match for both briefcases with James Storm teaming with Gunner and Magnus teaming with Carter. Later gave the contract to Storm.