มวยปล้ำสมัครเล่น

• Georgia State Tournament
  • Champion at 189 ปอนด์ (86 กิโลกรัม) weight class (2003, 2004)[1]

มวยปล้ำอาชีพ

• All Elite Wrestling
  • AEW TNT Championship (2 times, current)[92]
  • AEW TNT Championship Tournament (2020)[93]
• Alpha-1 Wrestling
  • A1 Tag Team Championship (1 time) – with Ethan Page[94]
• Bullet Proof Wrestling
  • BPW Championship (1 time)[95]
• CBS Sports
  • Promo of the Year (2019) – "Silver spoon" promo on AEW Dynamite[96]
  • Smack Talker of the Year (2019)[96]
• Global Force Wrestling
  • GFW NEX*GEN Championship (1 time)[97]
• National Wrestling Alliance
  • NWA World Heavyweight Championship (1 time)[98]
• New Japan Pro-Wrestling
  • IWGP United States Championship (1 time)[99]
• Northeast Wrestling
  • NEW Heavyweight Championship (1 time)[100]
• Ohio Valley Wrestling
  • OVW Heavyweight Championship (1 time)[1][17]
  • OVW Television Championship (1 time)[1][101]
  • OVW Southern Tag Team Championship (2 times) – with Shawn Spears[1][18]
  • Fourth OVW Triple Crown Champion[1][18][17][101]
• Pro Wrestling Illustrated
  • Match of the Year (2019) – vs. Dustin Rhodes at Double or Nothing[102][103]
  • Most Improved Wrestler of the Year (2008)[104]
  • Ranked No. 7 of the top 500 singles wrestlers in the PWI 500 in 2020[105]
• Ring of Honor
  • ROH World Championship (1 time)[73]
  • ROH World Six-Man Tag Team Championship (1 time) – with The Young Bucks
  • Wrestler of the Year (2017)[106]
  • Feud of the Year (2018) – vs. Kenny Omega[107]
• Sports Illustrated
  • Wrestler of the Year (2018)[108]
• What Culture Pro Wrestling
  • WCPW Internet Championship (1 time)[109]
• World Wrestling Entertainment/WWE
  • WWE Intercontinental Championship (2 times)[110][111]
  • WWE Tag Team Championship (3 times) – with Drew McIntyre (1) and Goldust (2)[112][113]
  • World Tag Team Championship (3 times) – with Hardcore Holly (1) and Ted DiBiase (2)[20][21][22]
  • Slammy Award (2 times)
    • Outstanding Achievement of Baby Oil Application (2010)[114]
    • Tag Team of the Year (2013) – with Goldust[115]
• Wrestling Observer Newsletter
  • Worst Gimmick (2015) as Stardust[116]