ซีดีซิงเกิลฉบับออสเตรเลีย[68]

1. "Don't Say You Love Me" – 3:46
2. "If Only Tears Could Bring You Back" โดยมิดไนต์ซันส์ (Midnight Sons) – 4:03
3. "Mewtwo Strikes Back Suite" – 4:51

• ส่วนพิเศษ

1. "Don't Say You Love Me" (music video) – 3:38

ซิงเกิลฉบับสหรัฐ[69]

1. "Don't Say You Love Me" (film version) – 3:46
2. "Mewtwo Strikes Back Suite" – 4:51

แมกซีซิงเกิลฉบับสหรัฐ[70]

1. "Don't Say You Love Me" (Tin Tin Out Remix) – 3:33
2. "Don't Say You Love Me" (Lenny Bertoldo Radio Mix) – 3:01
3. "Don't Say You Love Me" (acoustic version) – 3:15
4. "Don't Say You Love Me" (album version) – 3:46

แมกซีซิงเกิลฉบับญี่ปุ่น[71]

1. "Don't Say You Love Me" (album version) – 3:46
2. "Don't Say You Love Me" (Tin Tin Out Remix) – 3:33
3. "Don't Say You Love Me" (acoustic version) – 3:15
4. "The Feeling Is Gone" – 3:16 (non-album bonus track)
5. "Don't Say You Love Me" (karaoke version) – 4:06

แมกซีซิงเกิลฉบับยุโรป[72]

1. "Don't Say You Love Me" (album version) – 3:46
2. "The Feeling Is Gone" – 3:16
3. "Don't Say You Love Me" (acoustic version) – 3:15